Eine Plattform für die Wissenschaft: Bauingenieurwesen, Architektur und Urbanistik
Eine Plattform für die Wissenschaft: Bauingenieurwesen, Architektur und Urbanistik
Scrutinizing Virtual Citizen Involvement in Planning: Ten Applications of an Online Participatory Tool
How to organize citizen participation in planning is continuously debated. The amount of Online Participatory Tools (OPTs) to facilitate inclusive and efficient participation has increased. While studies have assessed their functionality, usability and effectiveness in planning, they have rarely analyzed OPTs beyond single-cases, targeted tools that are widely used or assessed how OPTs affect broader values of participation. Targeting this absence, this study analyzes how ten applications of a widely used OPT, CityPlanner™, affect the normative, substantive and instrumental values of citizen participatory planning in Swedish cities. By analyzing 1,354 citizen proposals and interviewing urban planners, we find that citizens more extensively submit proposals and initiate debates on planning when using the OPT. Results suggest a more even age and gender distribution among proposal users than with conventional methods, facilitating normative values of participation. The OPT was generally applied early in planning and generated high-quality inputs. Our results, however, nuance previous analyses by also emphasizing the importance of place-specificity of OPT applications and of joint participation strategies among departments. Key for OPT development includes the need to improve their ability to analyze overarching trends among inputs.
Scrutinizing Virtual Citizen Involvement in Planning: Ten Applications of an Online Participatory Tool
How to organize citizen participation in planning is continuously debated. The amount of Online Participatory Tools (OPTs) to facilitate inclusive and efficient participation has increased. While studies have assessed their functionality, usability and effectiveness in planning, they have rarely analyzed OPTs beyond single-cases, targeted tools that are widely used or assessed how OPTs affect broader values of participation. Targeting this absence, this study analyzes how ten applications of a widely used OPT, CityPlanner™, affect the normative, substantive and instrumental values of citizen participatory planning in Swedish cities. By analyzing 1,354 citizen proposals and interviewing urban planners, we find that citizens more extensively submit proposals and initiate debates on planning when using the OPT. Results suggest a more even age and gender distribution among proposal users than with conventional methods, facilitating normative values of participation. The OPT was generally applied early in planning and generated high-quality inputs. Our results, however, nuance previous analyses by also emphasizing the importance of place-specificity of OPT applications and of joint participation strategies among departments. Key for OPT development includes the need to improve their ability to analyze overarching trends among inputs.
Scrutinizing Virtual Citizen Involvement in Planning: Ten Applications of an Online Participatory Tool
Hjerpe, Mattias (Autor:in) / Glaas, Erik (Autor:in) / Storbjörk, Sofie (Autor:in)
28.09.2018
doi:10.17645/pag.v6i3.1481
Politics and Governance; Vol 6, No 3 (2018): Multidisciplinary Studies in Politics and Governance; 159-169 ; 2183-2463
Aufsatz (Zeitschrift)
Elektronische Ressource
Englisch
DDC:
710
| BASE | 2018
Digital Participatory Planning. Citizen Engagement, Democracy, and Design
| Taylor & Francis Verlag | 2024
Digital Participatory Planning: Citizen Engagement, Democracy, and Design
| Taylor & Francis Verlag | 2023