A platform for research: civil engineering, architecture and urbanism
A platform for research: civil engineering, architecture and urbanism
Politics of urban renewal: An anatomy of the conflicting discourses on the renovation of China's urban village
Abstract This paper attempts to analyse the politics of urban renewal through the anatomy of the conflicting discourses on the changes in China's urban villages. Specifically, this paper investigates the case of Liede Village, Guangzhou, a typical urban village in China, and its innovative reconstruction model. Based on the methods of participatory observation, in-depth interviews, and textual analysis, this paper finds that the official media conducted a top-down construction of Liede Village's reconstruction as a mainstream social and economic activity from which a modernised model for Chinese urban renewal has been strongly established; the villagers also respond to the strong construction of the official media coverage by conducting bottom-up protests that aim to safeguard their rights through alternative discourse constructions. In this sense, this study found that urban renewal is not only physical or socially related but politically related. There are significant differences in the discourse construction methods and operational logic of different power subjects. To resolve these conflicts, the discourse knowledge systems within urban villages should be reformed so that the Chinese government can more effectively govern these complex social spaces. This paper provides an alternative understanding of China's urban renewal from the perspective of discourse politics, which enriches existing studies on urban sustainability, social justice and urban governance for the wider human geographers, urban scholars and sociologists, especially the wider discussions on urban renewal in other countries.
Highlights Insufficient understanding of different stakeholders is the source of many social problems. Official media carries out a top-down construction of Liede Village’s reconstruction. Liede villagers responded to social injustices through bottom-up protests. Different power subjects have different discourse construction methods and practical logic. The methodology and main conclusions of this article are applicable to other countries.
Politics of urban renewal: An anatomy of the conflicting discourses on the renovation of China's urban village
Abstract This paper attempts to analyse the politics of urban renewal through the anatomy of the conflicting discourses on the changes in China's urban villages. Specifically, this paper investigates the case of Liede Village, Guangzhou, a typical urban village in China, and its innovative reconstruction model. Based on the methods of participatory observation, in-depth interviews, and textual analysis, this paper finds that the official media conducted a top-down construction of Liede Village's reconstruction as a mainstream social and economic activity from which a modernised model for Chinese urban renewal has been strongly established; the villagers also respond to the strong construction of the official media coverage by conducting bottom-up protests that aim to safeguard their rights through alternative discourse constructions. In this sense, this study found that urban renewal is not only physical or socially related but politically related. There are significant differences in the discourse construction methods and operational logic of different power subjects. To resolve these conflicts, the discourse knowledge systems within urban villages should be reformed so that the Chinese government can more effectively govern these complex social spaces. This paper provides an alternative understanding of China's urban renewal from the perspective of discourse politics, which enriches existing studies on urban sustainability, social justice and urban governance for the wider human geographers, urban scholars and sociologists, especially the wider discussions on urban renewal in other countries.
Highlights Insufficient understanding of different stakeholders is the source of many social problems. Official media carries out a top-down construction of Liede Village’s reconstruction. Liede villagers responded to social injustices through bottom-up protests. Different power subjects have different discourse construction methods and practical logic. The methodology and main conclusions of this article are applicable to other countries.
Politics of urban renewal: An anatomy of the conflicting discourses on the renovation of China's urban village
Zhao, Yongqi (author) / An, Ning (author) / Chen, Huiling (author) / Tao, Wei (author)
Cities ; 111
2020-12-17
Article (Journal)
Electronic Resource
English
Discourses of Citizenship in Transition: Scale, Politics and Urban Renewal
| British Library Conference Proceedings | 1999
Articles - Discourses of Citizenship in Transition: Scale, Politics and Urban Renewal
| Online Contents | 1999
MODERN STADIUM DESIGN: AN ADAPTIVE RENOVATION OR URBAN RENEWAL
| Online Contents | 2017
Gentrification effects of China's urban village renewals
| Online Contents | 2017
The Renewal of Urban Village — problems and potentials of Hongshan Village, Nanjing
| BASE | 2013