Liberal LGBTphobia in rural spaces: Israeli lesbian and bisexual women's relationality: Fid-Bau Portal

Liberal LGBTphobia in rural spaces: Israeli lesbian and bisexual women's relationality

Hartal, Gilly / Bar Tzedek, Yael

Abstract Lesbian and bisexual women living in rural space portray it as a multifaceted space, reflecting closeness to nature, good educational systems, and community life. But this idealized space, we argue, is also home to a specific form of LGBTphobia, which we conceptualize as Liberal LGBTphobia. While LGBTphobia is understood as originating in hatred or violence, liberal LGBTphobia is characterized by conservatism and ignorance towards LGBT people. However, influenced by a public-private divide, liberal LGBTphobia manifests in a dual discourse. On the one hand, it is anchored in the desirability of rural life for lesbian and bisexual women. This appeal makes it difficult to identify LGBTphobia as such in many instances, given that it manifests in subtle and complex ways. On the other hand, rural space is distinguished from its surrounding space; understood as a better place to live in and with fewer manifestations of LGBTphobia. Therefore, we conceptualize liberal LGBTphobia as consisting of a major mechanism that reproduces the “here” vs. “there” discourse within rural space, and from this identify specific practices that may not seem as LGBTphobia at first glance, such as shunning, prying, tokenism, gossip, and the use of politically correct language and social hints to convey a message of othering. These practices occur in rural space, where people live in comparatively small communities. We argue that liberal LGBTphobic practices are routine in contemporary rural Israeli space and communities.

Highlights • Liberal LGBTphobia is based on the relationality between rural and urban space. • Lesbian & bisexual women draw clear boundaries between rural-safe and urban-unsafe. • Participants view rurality as a fantasy of community and natural landscape. • Rurality is understood as closer to big citys than to adjacent small towns/cities. • Liberal LGBTphobia includes shunning, prying, tokenism, gossip, and PC language.